Emergency Preparedness

Creating an Emergency Response Plan: Where to Start

Start an emergency response plan by listing the five incidents most likely at your site and deciding who does what in the first ten minutes of each. Write that down, walk it with staff, and expand from there.

Seth Hershman

Seth Hershman · Former Yale Police detective, former CT DESPP policy advisor

· 7 min read

Creating an Emergency Response Plan: Where to Start

Everyone says you need an emergency response plan, but when you sit down to create one, where do you actually start?

Here is how to build one, in order, without getting buried.

Step 1: Identify Your Most Likely Scenarios

Don't try to plan for everything at once. Start with the most likely emergencies for your organization and location:

Common to Most Organizations:

  • Medical emergency (heart attack, fall, allergic reaction)
  • Fire
  • Severe weather (tornado, hurricane, etc., based on your region)
  • Utility failure (power outage, gas leak)
  • Suspicious person or threatening behavior

Consider Your Specific Context:

  • Are you in a flood zone?
  • Do you have large gatherings?
  • Do you serve vulnerable populations?
  • Are there specific threats you've experienced or been warned about?

Pick three to five scenarios to start, and add more later.

Step 2: Define Clear Response Procedures

For each scenario, document WHO does WHAT in simple, clear language.

Example: Medical Emergency During Service

  • Anyone who witnesses: Immediately notify safety team member or staff (how: hand signal, radio, etc.)
  • Safety team member: Assess situation, call 911 if needed, retrieve AED/first aid kit, provide care
  • Designated staff person: Meet emergency responders at entrance, guide them to location
  • Minister/leader: Continue service if possible, maintain calm
  • After incident: Document what happened, follow up with family, debrief team

Specific roles, specific actions, specific ways to communicate.

Step 3: Establish Communication Protocols

In an emergency, how do people communicate? Figure this out now, not during a crisis.

Internal Communication:

  • How do you alert your safety team? (radios, group text, hand signals)
  • How do you communicate with people in different parts of the building?
  • Who has authority to make emergency decisions?
  • How do you notify everyone of an evacuation or lockdown?

External Communication:

  • Who calls 911? (Designate primary and backup)
  • Who speaks to media if they arrive?
  • How do you notify families of those affected?
  • What's your social media policy during emergencies?

Step 4: Assign Roles and Responsibilities

Great plans fail because no one knows it's their job to execute them.

Create a Basic Response Team:

  • Team Lead: Makes decisions, coordinates response
  • Medical Response: Handles medical emergencies (first aid/CPR trained)
  • Building Security: Secures access points, manages evacuation/lockdown
  • Communication: Calls 911, relays information to team
  • Children/Vulnerable Populations: Ensures safety of children and those who need assistance

For smaller organizations, people can wear multiple hats. Just make sure everyone knows their role.

Step 5: Map Your Facility

Create or update floor plans showing:

  • All exits
  • Emergency equipment locations (AED, fire extinguishers, first aid kits, shut-off valves)
  • Assembly points for evacuations
  • Shelter locations for severe weather
  • Lockdown rooms if applicable

Post these maps in visible locations. Give copies to emergency responders (police, fire) during non-emergency visits.

Step 6: Build Your Emergency Kit

Have basic supplies readily accessible:

Medical:

  • First aid kit
  • AED (if you don't have one, budget for one)
  • Emergency medications for known conditions (if applicable)

Communication:

  • Two-way radios or backup phones
  • Emergency contact list (key staff, local police/fire, utility companies)

Supplies:

  • Flashlights and batteries
  • Water
  • Emergency blankets

Step 7: Train Your People

What saves lives in the moment is not the plan on paper but the people who have trained on it.

Essential Training:

  • All staff and volunteers: Basic awareness of procedures, how to report emergencies
  • Response team: Detailed training on their specific roles
  • Medical responders: First aid/CPR/AED certification (renew every 2 years)
  • Leadership: Decision-making protocols, communication strategies

Run Drills:

Schedule at least one drill per year for each scenario:

  • Fire evacuation
  • Severe weather shelter
  • Medical emergency (tabletop)
  • Lockdown (if applicable)

Drills reveal the gaps in your plan, which is the point of running them.

Step 8: Document Everything Simply

Your plan should be:

  • Written: In clear, simple language
  • Accessible: Where people can find it quickly
  • Brief: People won't read a 50-page document in a crisis

Create Quick Reference Cards:

Laminated one-page cards for each scenario that anyone can follow. Post them in strategic locations.

Step 9: Review and Update Annually

Review the plan every year and after any incident:

  • Have contact numbers changed?
  • Have roles changed?
  • Did drills reveal problems?
  • Have new threats emerged?
  • Have you renovated or changed building layout?

Step 10: Connect with Local Emergency Services

Don't wait for an emergency to build relationships:

  • Invite local police/fire for facility tours
  • Share your floor plans and emergency contact list
  • Ask for their input on your plan
  • Attend community emergency preparedness meetings

Don't Let Perfect Be the Enemy of Good

The best emergency response plan is the one you have and use, not the perfect one you never finish.

Start with one scenario, write down the basic procedures, train a few people, and run one drill. Then build from there.

Need Professional Help?

We write emergency response plans that staff can follow under stress. Contact us for a consultation.

Questions About Your Own Building?

Tell us what you are dealing with and we will tell you where we would start.